The Big DNS Privacy Debate at FOSDEM
This weekend at the excellent FOSDEM gathering there were no less than three presentations on DNS over HTTPs. Daniel Stenberg presented a keynote session “DNS over HTTPS – the good, the bad and the ugly” (video), Vittorio Bertola discussed “The DoH Dilemma” while Daniel, Stéphane Bortzmeyer and I formed a DNS Privacy Panel expertly moderated by Jan-Piet Mens. I want to thank Daniel, Jan-Piet, Rudolf van der Berg, Stéphane & Vittorio for proofreading & improving this post, but I should add this does not imply an endorsement from anyone!
In what follows, I will attempt to give a neutral description of what I think we learned, and where we now are on DoH, with a focus on the European perspective. If you find a noticeable bias, please let me know urgently and I’ll address it. But to be clear, I’m no fan of centralizing DNS on a small number of cloud providers.
After the neutral description you will find some strong opinions on if “DNS over Cloud” is a good thing or not. During the FOSDEM presentations, various visions on the desirability of DNS over HTTPS were discussed. We were sadly rather hampered by messy definitions.
There are two definitions that sound the same but are different in practice. Firstly, there is “DNS over HTTPS” (DoH) which is a transport protocol so you can securely ask DNS queries over HTTPS. Secondly, Google, Firefox and Cloudflare are working on using DoH to move DNS queries from the network service provider straight onto the cloud.
In other words, where previously your service provider could see (and answer) your DNS queries, in this proposed future you would send your DNS requests to a “free-as-in-beer” cloud provider.